Marketers spend months building campaigns to grab attention and drive leads. But there is one thing that can quietly kill conversion rates no matter how great the creative is — what people find when they Google you.
A single bad review, outdated article, or negative blog post can undo months of brand-building work. If you are wondering whether cleaning up your online presence can actually help your marketing results, the short answer is yes. The longer answer is in this guide.
Table of Contents
Why Your Online Presence Affects Marketing Performance
Marketing works best when your audience trusts you. If the first thing they see after clicking an ad is a negative article or a 1-star review, that trust collapses.
BrightLocal’s 2024 survey found that 87% of people read online reviews before making a purchase. In B2B, the number is even higher. That means your marketing spend is directly tied to what people see in search results.
One SaaS company I worked with saw this firsthand. They were running high-converting ad campaigns, but their close rate dropped 40% after a negative industry blog post ranked on page one for their brand name.
Audit What People See
Before you can fix your online presence, you need to know what’s out there. Start with a branded search in incognito mode and look at:
- The first two pages of search results
- Google Images and Google News
- Major review sites like Google Business, Yelp, and Trustpilot
Look for anything that could hurt your credibility. Outdated bios, old press coverage, or negative reviews all count.
Remove What You Can
Some content can be taken down entirely. Contact site owners directly if the information is outdated, incorrect, or violates their terms of service.
For example, a small business owner I know had a decade-old news article about a dismissed lawsuit. She reached out to the editor with proof of the dismissal. The article was removed within a week, and her branded search traffic improved almost immediately.
If you cannot get it removed on your own, online content removal services can help. They know the right legal and procedural paths to take, and they can often get faster results.
Suppress What You Cannot Remove
Not all negative content can be deleted. In those cases, the goal is to push it down in search results by creating new, positive, and authoritative content.
This might include:
- Publishing regular blog posts or articles on high-authority sites
- Getting interviewed on podcasts or industry publications
- Creating video content for YouTube and optimizing it for your brand name
A retail brand in Chicago used this approach after bad Yelp reviews started ranking for their name. Within six months of consistent content posting, those reviews moved off page one and their ad conversion rate rebounded.
Keep Building a Positive Presence
Once you clean things up, do not stop. A strong online presence is easier to maintain than to rebuild.
Update your website regularly. Keep your social media profiles active. Post case studies, testimonials, and positive press mentions.
This also makes you more resistant to future issues. If a negative article appears, it will have to fight for space against your established positive content.
Tie Reputation Management to Your Marketing KPIs
Treat your online presence like part of your marketing funnel. Track how branded search impressions, click-through rates, and conversions change after you clean up search results.
One marketing agency found that clients with a strong first page of search results saw an average 18% increase in conversion rates from paid campaigns compared to those with mixed or negative results. That is a clear ROI story you can bring to leadership.
Tools and Services That Can Help
Here are three reliable options for keeping your online presence clean and your marketing strong:
- Erase – Specializes in removing harmful or outdated search results and replacing them with accurate, positive content. Strong choice for both individuals and brands.
- Reputation Galaxy – Focuses on long-term suppression strategies and brand-building campaigns to protect search results from negative content.
- Brandwatch – Offers real-time monitoring for brand mentions across the web, so you can catch problems before they hurt your campaigns.
Mistakes to Avoid
Only reacting when there is a problem – Proactive monitoring is cheaper and more effective than crisis cleanup.
Relying only on ads to win trust – Paid traffic will still Google you before buying.
Ignoring image and video results – A bad photo or video can show up just as prominently as a bad review.
Not tracking the impact – If you do not measure results, you cannot prove the value of the cleanup work.
The Payoff for Marketing
A strong online presence turns your marketing into a trust machine. Every ad, email, and social post benefits from the fact that people find positive and accurate information about you.
It also gives you room to experiment with bigger, bolder campaigns. When your reputation is solid, you can take more creative risks without fear that one bad headline will sink the results.
Cleaning up your online presence is not just good PR. It is a marketing multiplier. Done right, it can turn curious clicks into confident customers — and keep them coming back.